Returns and credit notes: correcting VAT properly

In online retail, returns are part of the business. A mere return of goods or a credit note does not automatically lead to a change in the VAT tax base. What matters is whether the consideration has actually changed. In that case, VAT must be corrected under § 17 UStG. The credit note within the meaning of § 14 UStG, that is, billing by the recipient of the service, is to be distinguished from this. Many merchants book this only roughly, and that is exactly where discrepancies in audits arise.

The basic rule

If the consideration is reduced afterwards, VAT must be corrected accordingly (§ 17 UStG). The correction is made in the advance return period in which the reduction occurred.

Example: An item is sold for 119 euros gross, so it includes 19 euros of VAT. If it comes back and the customer is refunded, the VAT is reduced by 19 euros. What matters is the time at which the reduction of the consideration occurs. This time determines the advance return period.

Returns and credit notes

A return with a full refund is a reduction of the consideration. A commercial credit note, for example as a goodwill gesture or discount, is not automatically a VAT credit note within the meaning of § 14 UStG. What is decisive is whether and when the consideration is actually reduced. The credit note must be properly documented and linked to the original invoice.

Partial refunds, allowances or discounts after the sale work in the same way. Refunding shipping costs on a return also reduces the consideration.

Marketplaces and statements

On marketplaces, the platform often settles fees, refunds and returns through its own statements. These statements must be reconciled with your own bookkeeping. If revenue, refunds and fees do not match, it stands out in an audit.

Reporting under the Platform Tax Transparency Act (PStTG, the implementation of DAC7) is in principle made by the platform operator that has the reporting obligation, not by the individual merchant. The VAT booking of a return and the DAC7 report are to be distinguished from one another. Platform statements do, however, help with reconciliation against your own figures. A clean allocation to order and return numbers prevents double entry.

In practice: keeping the correction auditable

  1. Record returns with order number, return date and refund amount.
  2. Book refunds as reversal entries in the period in which the reduction of the consideration occurs, not on the sale date.
  3. Reconcile the shop export, the payment provider and the bookkeeping every month.
  4. Number credit notes consecutively and link them to the original invoice.
  5. Keep the goods value of returned items separate from revenue.

Frequently asked questions

Do I have to correct VAT for every return?
Yes, as soon as the consideration is reduced. A mere return that has not yet been decided does not yet reduce the consideration. Once the reversal is certain, the later payout date plays no decisive role for the time of the correction.

When exactly do I correct the VAT?
In the advance return period in which the reduction of the consideration occurs. That is not automatically the purchase and not automatically the payout date. What matters is when the tax base changes (§ 17 para. 1 UStG), that is, when return and reduction are established. A reversal that is already certain is not postponed to a later period merely because of a later payout.

What about vouchers for customers?
A voucher can have its own tax treatment, depending on whether it is a single-purpose or multi-purpose voucher. This is explained in the article on vouchers in the beauty studio.

Further reading: Efficient bookkeeping for online retailers · DAC7 and platforms

Next step: Do you sell online and want to book returns and credit notes cleanly? Learn more about our tax advisory for e-commerce.

Weitere News &
Insights

Kontakt

Sie haben eine Frage oder ein Anliegen?